The visible hand in economics

July 08 OCR decision: Rates cut to 8.0%

Posted on: July 24, 2008

So the Reserve Bank cut interest rates to 8.0%.

The only new information that has come out since June is a higher inflation outcome as a result of larger than expected increases in petrol and food prices. Furthermore recent increases in funding costs have helped to convince the Bank to cut.

Even ignoring inflation, it appears that the Reserve Bank values the livelihood of those who have mortgages above people who are struggling to pay their food and fuel bills (which will go up, as a lower exchange rate will increase the New Zealand price of both).

Good Bloomberg piece here.

More discussion to come later (the additional discussion has now appeared).

15 Responses to "July 08 OCR decision: Rates cut to 8.0%"

I’m surprised. I’d have guessed no more than 1/3 chance they’d have made the cut. Now, do I revise my expectation about the extent to which the Bank fails to care about inflation, my expectation about the real economic data, or both?

“Now, do I revise my expectation about the extent to which the Bank fails to care about inflation”

I ignored inflation above because I think it is obvious that the back doesn’t care about inflation anymore.

Well, it could be that they’ve moved from not caring about it at all to positively preferring it.

Isn’t it something special that we are seeing rate cuts at the same time as inflation is expected to hit 5%.

The current RBNZ has all the markings of time-inconsistency that comes with discretionary policy – it will make a good case study in how not to perform monetary policy in about 10 years.

it is a time inconsistency problem, but the reasons for the inconsistency I see as this;

The reason for the current high prices is the booming worldwide economy over the past few years. This boom has ended yet we are still suffering from increasing costs. increasing interest rates at this stage would do little positive about this because it is the effect of the past few years. by lowering rates it keeps the economy moving. the negative outcomes of keeping interest rates high are worse for the economy. If I am wrong can you clarify? i’m not a macroeconomist.

I also have a feeling that there has been some sort of govt discussion to take the focus off solely being on inflation. Similar to overseas jurisdictions where monetary policy is based on many factors, not just inflation. while in NZ officially it is only inflation, the govt/RB probably has a wider view of its responsibilities.

Who says inflation is expected to hit 5%? I would have thought that inflation expectations are starting to curb, but the economy is looking fragile, so lowering rates makes sense… no?

I have this awful feeling that this was not the right move. Many will now expect cost pressures to ease when they will not. Further for manufacturers who use imported materials costs will now go up, thus increasing the incentives to relocate production off shore.

Fuel costs will rise further, thus forcing prices up. In turn this will stoke wage demands.

I would not be surprised, if there is a change of government and perhaps even if no change, to see some labour action post election.

I am perhaps too pessimistic, but see the hovering spectre of a lengthy recession and perhaps stagflation?

[…] interesting order of priorities! The OCR cut. The Visible Hand in Economics comments on the OCR cut: Even ignoring inflation, it appears that the Reserve Bank values the livelihood of […]

[…] TVHE comments: Even ignoring inflation, it appears that the Reserve Bank values the livelihood of those who have mortgages above people who are struggling to pay their food and fuel bills (which will go up, as a lower exchange rate will increase the New Zealand price of both). […]

I’m no economist, but to me this looks like consistent (but wrong) behaviour.

The Reserve Bank was woefully slow to raise interest rates during 2004 to 2005 and has now eased far too quickly. Is there some other agenda beyond fighting inflation that us non-economists are unaware of?

[…] July 2008 official cash rate cut: The long and winding road 24 07 2008 So the Reserve Bank has cut interest rates. […]

Hi all,

Hello Steve,

“increasing interest rates at this stage would do little positive about this because it is the effect of the past few years”

The higher interest rates are not meant to account for recent increases in food and fuel prices – they are meant to keep inflation expectations anchored. As a result, we have to ask the question, are inflation expectations (the amount people are going to add to their price to account for inflation) anchored?

“I also have a feeling that there has been some sort of govt discussion to take the focus off solely being on inflation”

The Bank does not have a sole inflation mandate – it is just its primary mandate. Ultimately, the Bank is supposed to control inflationary pressures now in order to promote long-term growth. The ability to do this is debatable, however this does not mean we should give the Reserve Bank a wider mandate and only one tool – if you have to achieve many things with only one tool it is usually very different (especially when the tool pushes them in opposite directions).

“Who says inflation is expected to hit 5%? I would have thought that inflation expectations are starting to curb, but the economy is looking fragile, so lowering rates makes sense… no?”

Everyone is saying inflation will hit 5% now, even the Bank. I said it first though 😉

Inflation expectations are not starting to curb, annual price growth has been so persistently high that it has lead to higher trend inflation expectations – that is the issue ultimately.

Hi Adam,

“I am perhaps too pessimistic, but see the hovering spectre of a lengthy recession and perhaps stagflation?”

I find it hard to see a depression in New Zealand – our terms of trade is at its highest point since 1974. A drought and oil price shock caused a recession, no doubt, but if economic activity starts to pick up in December (given the strong income growth that comes from higher commodity prices) you can bet your bottom dollar that the economy will recover. However, inflation will reappear.

The Bank is worried that domestic demand is going to contract VERY quickly and remain VERY low for a protracted period of time. It is possible – but its not the situation I would put money on.

“The Reserve Bank was woefully slow to raise interest rates during 2004 to 2005 and has now eased far too quickly. Is there some other agenda beyond fighting inflation that us non-economists are unaware of?”

I’m not sure, maybe they do have other motives 🙂

I agree that they raised too slowly and that they have eased too early – however, a lot of other economists agree with them. I think many economists believe that “now is different” in regards to inflation – given that labour market institutions are a lot more flexible. However, I’m not so sure that this is the case, given that the rising skills of labour have effectively increased their bargaining position, making it easier for inflation expectations to translation into inflation.

We will see I guess.

[…] anyone know why ASB cut mortgage rates following the OCR decision?  Bank credit funding costs have been going through the roof – which is why the RBNZ felt that it […]

[…] Read the rest of this great post here […]

Healthy Weight reduction For A Fifteen Year Old?Get prepared for a life story guysSo, Ive often been over-weight. Normally. Im going to be fifteen in june, and Im already a large or an XL is shops like abercrombie, Aritzia, aeropostale, all those retailers. My thighs are large and jiggly, my stomach, lets just say it may very well be quite a bit superior, and my arms are flabby. Ive attempted to consume healthier and that lasts for about three days. I dont consume a great deal of junk food, but you know, I could cut back. Whenever I attempt to talk to my mom about she just says, Youre perfect just the way youre. Youre eye-catching honey, you do not require to shed weight. But Im not comfy going to stores and going to the checkout with major sizes. Im just not comfy with myself. We do not have any funds for a health club membership, or a home gym, so all of the activity I would do, would need to be with out any gear. I also desire to do it behind my moms back, I dont wish to, but thats just the way it truly is. So heres the shocker Im 145 pounds and Im fourteen, Im not obese (says my wii fit), but Im not common, Im overweight. And I hate it, I. HATE. IT. I do not need to be the girl in high school whos fat. You know? There is continually that girl. So, are there anyways I could eat healthier, without asking my mom to buy all unique dieting foods? Like, limiting portions and stuff? And some excersises I could do that would make me drop the weight on my legs, arms and stomach fast. Properly, not like a single month quick, because that is not healthy, but Id like to be about 110, so id must drop 35 POUNDS! Which is crazy difficult, considering my metabolism is slow. Im sorry for rambling on about my life story, but I want help with eating habits and fitness workouts, without my mom knowing. THANKS A MILLION! like you guys on here!

really useful Here’s some pass forward: Thought for the day? : I do whatever my rice crispies tell me to.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Add to Google
%d bloggers like this: